Why Companies Fail at Execution and How to Get It Right

Change Activation

Why Companies Fail at Execution and How to Get It Right

Why Companies Fail at Execution and How to Get It Right

About this brief

What is the ECLC? The Executive Council for Leading Change (ECLC) is a global, peer-led community of more than 1,200 enterprise transformation leaders. Members meet in regular virtual roundtables of around 45 executives, held under Chatham House rules, to share what is working, what is not, and how they are handling change.


How Tigerhall fits. ECLC is convened by Tigerhall, the transformation delivery platform for a world of always-on change. Tigerhall turns a companyโ€™s strategy into personalized change journeys for each employee, delivered in the flow of work (Teams, Slack, Outlook, mobile) in 33 languages, with real-time data on where the change is landing and where it is stalling. Leaders own the strategy and the plan; Tigerhall runs the delivery, so a team of two or three can deliver what used to take fifteen to twenty.


What is an executive brief? An ECLC executive brief is a short, anonymised write-up of a single roundtable. It captures what the room discussed, where leaders agreed and differed, and what to do next. Each opens with a summary, then themed sections, then eight key takeaways.


Executive Summary for Why Companies Fail at Execution and How to Get It Right

A guest author and former enterprise executive challenged the habit of writing a strategy and handing it to a transformation team to deliver. Most strategies fail on execution, not on the quality of the idea, and the usual cause is that strategy and execution are treated as separate jobs done by separate groups. Employees often cannot name their companyโ€™s strategy or their role in it, and few managers trust peers in other functions. Closing that gap is worth a large share of the revenue and profit a strategy promised.


Execution is designed up front, and a six-part system makes that practical: co-creation, clarity, capacity, communication, coordination and coaching. The extra time spent early comes back many times over later.


The Strategy Trap

  • A famous retail reversal. A celebrated retail executive launched an ambitious pricing strategy without testing it in stores or building internal alignment. Sales fell by a quarter and he was out within seventeen months. The idea may have been sound. The strategy was not executable.

  • A familiar pattern. Big announcement, early excitement, shifting priorities, fading communication, and a new strategy joining last yearโ€™s in the archive.

  • Strategy is a script, not a production. A script handed to actors and pushed on stage is not a show. The most successful productions spend years rehearsing, testing and iterating before opening night.

  • Slow down to speed up. Skipping the groundwork only moves the slowdown to a worse moment.


Co-Creation: Alignment, Validation, Commitment

  • Break the bubble. Strategies written by a small group in isolation lack buy-in. Bring in the people who will implement them.

  • Ownership effect. People value what they help build far more than what they are handed. Research found those who assembled furniture themselves valued it roughly 60% more.

  • Validate in structured ways. Use perspective-switching sessions where everyone wears the optimist hat, then the risk hat, and so on. Run pre-mortems that imagine the failure before it happens. Share unfinished work and invite people to poke holes in it.

  • Aim for 70% alignment and 100% commitment. Full agreement is unrealistic. Seven out of ten is enough to move the question from โ€œwill this work?โ€ to โ€œhow do we make it work?โ€


Clarity

  • Say what you are not doing. Explicit โ€œnotsโ€ sharpen what you are doing. Example: expanding beyond the office, not abandoning it; targeting one customer segment, not everyone.

  • Build a common language. Disagreements often come from different levels of abstraction rather than different ideas. Move up and down the ladder from vision to plan to tactics so every level can connect to the concrete.

  • Make it meaningful to individuals. Organizations that link strategy to personal purpose report materially higher productivity, engagement and retention. In a well-known space-program story, even the janitor could say he was helping put a person on the moon, because objectives cascaded from the mission to his work.

  • Delegate the how. Give guiding principles, constraints and clear objectives, then let teams choose how to deliver, with dated initiatives and named owners.

Capacity

  • Start by stopping. Keep a stop-doing list. One of the most dangerous words in business is โ€œyesโ€.

  • Retire โ€œbuilding the plane while flying it.โ€ Review what is on the plate, ask whether it supports the priorities, and ask whether you would start it again today.

  • Stack rank. High/medium/low ratings push every item to โ€œhighโ€. Research suggests that as an executiveโ€™s priority list grows, revenue growth falls. Insist on a true number one, two and three.

  • Make the math visible. One team felt overloaded but could not say why. Mapping it showed roughly 300 available hours against about 600 hours of committed work, and decisions followed.

  • Four answers, not two. Yes, yes if something changes, not yet, and no.


Communication

  • Early, loud and continuous. Lay the groundwork before launch, cut through noise, and repeat.

  • The illusion of communication. People nod and smile in a conversation without absorbing it. Use town halls, team kickoffs, written updates and two-way listening sessions.

  • Beat the forgetting curve. People forget most of what they learn within a month unless it is reinforced across channels and cadences.


Coordination

  • Accountability charts, not org charts. Map who is accountable for which decisions. Frame accountability as a team sport, not a turf claim.

  • Red-flag reviews. Regular checkpoints with strong psychological safety surface problems early, with cross-functional handoffs agreed in advance.

  • Manage up for the team. It unlocks decisions, resources and political cover.

  • Cross-functional initiatives. Initiatives and OKRs should cut across functions, each with one accountable leader. Functional leaders stay accountable for delivering their contribution.


Coaching

  • Culture is what you celebrate minus what you tolerate.

  • Manage the game as it unfolds. Use metrics to know the score at any time and keep the team off shiny objects.

  • Do only what only you can do. Leaders buried in messages need to free themselves for the work only they can do.


Questions from the Room

  • Time-poor owners. A leader in a newly independent company with owners who want speed asked how to compress the process. The answer: choose between being first to the starting line and first to the finish line. One small company completed most of the system in two dedicated days, instead of spending the same time polishing a deck. Months of wordsmithing before validation is the wrong order.

  • Experiments that grow. Keep the north star and expected outcome explicit. Ask whether a new idea beats the path you are on, and resist projecting a big future onto a small early sign.

  • AI strategy. Most often AI is a way to enable the strategy you already have, not a strategy in itself. Stay on the path and use AI to speed up tasks such as drafting and validation.

  • Business as usual versus new initiatives. Leaders must trade something off. Reduce (meetings), reuse (duplicated work) and recycle (move capable people from low-value to high-value areas).

  • Operations and transformation. Stabilize operations so transformation gets focus, stop work that does not add value, and measure both leading and lagging indicators with a feedback loop. Keep a hierarchy that connects initiative metrics to the north-star metric.

  • Action-oriented cultures. Execution begins with the upfront steps. Co-creation, clarity and capacity do not have to take long, though the trade-off decisions are the hard part.

  • New-thing aversion. Repeated failed strategies breed cynicism. Run validation sessions in small groups across the organization. People accept decisions more readily when they feel heard, a principle called procedural justice.

  • Short-term OKRs masquerading as strategy. Strategy should be a three-to-five-year path, not each functionโ€™s annual wish list. Hold leaders accountable only after you have created the conditions: clarity, co-creation and capacity.

  • Capacity versus prioritization. They are two sides of the same problem. Stack rank first, then fund from the top, and reduce the time lost to getting clear.


Key Takeaways

  1. Treat strategy and execution as one job, not a handoff.

  2. Co-create and validate with the people who will deliver it, aiming for 70% alignment and full commitment.

  3. Say what you are not doing, and keep language concrete.

  4. Connect every role to the mission through cascaded objectives.

  5. Stop work before starting new work, and stack rank priorities.

  6. Communicate early, loudly and repeatedly, because the illusion of communication is the biggest risk.

  7. Use cross-functional initiatives with one accountable leader each.

  8. Create the conditions first, then hold people accountable.

Trusted Change Strategies Straight to your Inbox

Trusted Change Strategies Straight to your Inbox

Tap into the latest insights and proven success blueprints from change leaders around the world.

Tap into the latest insights and proven success blueprints from change leaders around the world.

ECLC logo

Meet Your Peers,
Join the Action.

ECLC logo

ECLC Conference 2026

The AI Summit for
Transformation Leaders

October 8, 2026, 7:30AM ET
City Winery, New York City

How Well is Your Org Activating Change?